File #: 21-1168    Version: 1
Type: Agenda Item Status: Approved
File created: 7/8/2021 In control: Board of Supervisors
On agenda: 7/27/2021 Final action: 7/27/2021
Title: HEARING - Health and Human Services Agency recommending the Board conduct a public hearing to consider an appeal submitted regarding the El Dorado County Veterans Alliance decision to honor Captain Paul Jacobs, pursuant to the “El Dorado Veterans Monument Criteria for Military Honoraria and Civilian Recognition”; the appeal challenges whether the determination to place the bronze plaque on the honor wall of the El Dorado Veterans Monument meets process requirements and eligibility criteria. FUNDING: N/A
Attachments: 1. A - Veterans Monument Criteria, 2. B - Ordinance 9.54.010., 3. C - Appeal Letter #1 May 2021, 4. D - Chartered Vet Organizations Hearing Video 6.21.21, 5. E - Appeal Letter #2 July 2021, 6. G - Appeal Discovery 718.docx, 7. H - Appeal Discovery 716B, 8. Public Comment Rcvd 7-23-2021 BOS 7-27-2021, 9. Letter of Mansfield, 10. Appeal and Exhibits, 11. Public Comment BOS Rcvd 7-27-21, 12. Public Comment BOS Rcvd 7-20-21, 13. Appellants Handouts BOS Rcvd 7-27-2021 BOS 7-27-2021.pdf
Related files: 07-394
Title
HEARING - Health and Human Services Agency recommending the Board conduct a public hearing to consider an appeal submitted regarding the El Dorado County Veterans Alliance decision to honor Captain Paul Jacobs, pursuant to the “El Dorado Veterans Monument Criteria for Military Honoraria and Civilian Recognition”; the appeal challenges whether the determination to place the bronze plaque on the honor wall of the El Dorado Veterans Monument meets process requirements and eligibility criteria.

FUNDING: N/A
Body
DISCUSSION / BACKGROUND
On April 3, 2007, representatives of the Friends of the Veterans Monument, commanders of the County's veteran services organizations, and Veterans Commission met with County staff from the Chief Administrative Office, County Counsel, and Veterans Affairs to discuss the management of the Veterans Memorial Monument. The meeting resulted in two action items for the group to complete: a document outlining the regulations concerning the use of the monument and a document that outlines the criteria for governing the levels of distinction of honorable and distinguished service for the determination of the location of recognition on the monument. From these discussions, the "Veterans Monument Criteria for Military Honoraria and Civilian Recognition" was developed to provide information regarding eligibility criteria for and types of recognition through military honoraria at the monument plaza, the application process for applying to be honored, as well as the process for any issues or concerns regarding inclusion or location of honoraria. On September 11, 2007, (Item# 07-394) the Board of Supervisors adopted Ordinance Number 4743 establishing regulations for the use of the Veterans Memorial Monument and providing amendments to the Criteria for Military Honoraria and Civilian Recognition (See Attachments A and B).

Recently, in May 2021, representatives of the El Dorado County Veterans Alliance (formerly the "Friends of the Veteran...

Click here for full text