File #: 21-0691    Version: 1
Type: Agenda Item Status: Continued
File created: 4/16/2021 In control: Board of Supervisors
On agenda: 5/4/2021 Final action:
Title: HEARING - To consider an appeal from the April 9, 2021 decision of the Administrative Hearing Officer in Code Enforcement case CE20-0198 (Exhibit E). The appeal is filed by Thomas Swett, attorney for property owner All About Equine, and challenges the ruling of the Hearing Officer upholding Code Enforcement determination that the gate placed by All About Equine across a non-county maintained public right-of-way requires a permit under El Dorado County Code section 130.30.030. Planning and Building Department recommending the Board: 1) Find that the gates in question are in violation of County Code Section 130.30.030; and 2) Deny the appeal and uphold the decision of the Hearing Officer.
Attachments: 1. A CE20-0198 Notice to Correct, 2. B County code 130.30.0900 - Gates, 3. C Hearing Binder, 4. D Hearing Officer Decision, 5. E Appeal to BOS, 6. F Respondents Brief, 7. G Petitioners Response to Respondent's Brief, 8. H Respondent's Reply Brief, 9. I Respondent's Exhibit F Site Map
Title
HEARING - To consider an appeal from the April 9, 2021 decision of the Administrative Hearing Officer in Code Enforcement case CE20-0198 (Exhibit E). The appeal is filed by Thomas Swett, attorney for property owner All About Equine, and challenges the ruling of the Hearing Officer upholding Code Enforcement determination that the gate placed by All About Equine across a non-county maintained public right-of-way requires a permit under El Dorado County Code section 130.30.030.

Planning and Building Department recommending the Board:
1) Find that the gates in question are in violation of County Code Section 130.30.030; and
2) Deny the appeal and uphold the decision of the Hearing Officer.
Body
DISCUSSION / BACKGROUND
Code Enforcement Officer Todd Young conducted a site visit on 4/30/2020 and determined that a gate had been placed across a non-county maintained public right-of-way in violation of County Ordinance 130.30.070 Gates. A Notice to Correct was sent to the property owner on 5/5/2020 (Exhibit A). The owner's representative, Thomas Swett, requested an Administrative Hearing on 5/13/2020. With COVID-19 protocols in place, staff contacted the owner in a letter dated 5/20/2020 advising that hearings were postponed until further notice. On 7/2/2020, Mr. Swett informed the Code Enforcement Division that he was now the representative for the property owner and the primary contact for this case. He requested a Notice of Compliance be recorded, arguing the correction notice was "erroneously issued and should be rescinded." On 9/16/2020, he sent another communication requesting a Notice of Compliance. On November 3, 2020, a meeting was held with Planning staff to discuss the zoning and options, no resolution was determined. On 2/17/2021, staff contacted Mr. Swett to schedule the Administrative Hearing to be held on 3/10/2021. The hearing was held on 3/10/21, whereby both sides agreed the facts were essentially undisputed, but did not agree with the inter...

Click here for full text